Carmarthen Quins
2016/2017 Fosters Challenge Cup
Quins 33 v 14 Swansea
19 October 2016 - The Park, Carmarthen

Match Report

Carmarthen Quins 33 Swansea 14

To watch full-screen: click on the slideshow title and open fully in YouTube.


By: Paul Hopkins


Carmarthen eased to a bonus point victory over the All Whites to keep up their 100 per cent record in the Fosters Cup.


The defeat left Swansea’s qualification hopes in tatters and it’s likely that they would need to win the remainder of their four games to have any hope of progressing to the next stage.


The home pack set the tone in the opening exchanges by driving the Swansea pack off the ball. Carmarthen were awarded a penalty and fly half Steffan Marshall kicked to touch, although the Whites’ defence stood firm.


When visitors’ winger Jonathan Bayliss dropped the ball under little pressure near his own line, the signs looked ominous for the Swansea pack, but the Quins forwards were penalised for an infringement at the scrum.


Flanker Rory Gallagher was shown a yellow card for killing the ball and Carmarthen again opted for a close range scrum. This time there was nothing the Whites’ forwards could do as they were pushed backwards, giving referee Richard Brace no option but to award a penalty try. Marshall converted.


When the visitors did get their hands on the ball they looked threatening. Number eight Jon Fox made a barnstorming run through the middle and was supported by hooker Alex Dunham, who side-stepped past a tackle. The backs got the ball out wide for winger Will Lewis to touch down in the corner. Fly half Jac Wilson converted.


When the visitors failed to roll away after the tackle, Marshall again opted not to take the simple three points, but to kick to the corner. The home forwards looked destined for the line, but a combination of lock Rhys Morgan and Fox drove them into touch to save a certain try.


Marshall was then penalised for holding onto the ball in the tackle, but Wilson missed a relatively easy kick at goal.


The theme of home dominance at the scum continued and it paid off when the Quins got the ball quickly out of the set piece, with centre Callum Price taking a pass on the angle, allowing him to sprint clear to score. Marshall converted.


With 40 minutes up both sides were keen to keep the ball alive as they went in search for a score. First it was the visitors’ who went on the attack, but their move broke down and centre Elliot Davies made a break in midfield and he was supported by replacement scrum half Aled James. He found winger Morgan Griffiths, who showed a stunning turn of pace to sprint clear to score. Marshall’s conversion was successful.


Half-time:-   Carmarthen   21   Swansea   7


After the interval Swansea embarked on an attack through Wilson and centre Ewan Gully, but they lost possession as they ventured over the Quins’ twenty-two.


Instead it was the home side who secured a bonus point when their forwards mauled forward to send flanker Andrew Green crashing over for a try from close range. Marshall missed the conversion.


Centre David Watts then took forward a crash ball, with flanker Chris James in support, forcing Carmarthen offside at the break down. Full back Phil Jones kicked for touch, but Swansea were unable to make the most of a good attacking position.


Watts made a superb break and was brought down a metre short of the line. Lewis and Bayliss linked up well, but James dropped the ball to give Carmarthen a reprieve.


With eight minutes remaining the All Whites were handed a lifeline when the Quins were penalised for a scrummaging infringement. Phil Jones kicked to the corner and he collected the ball in midfield from the lineout to feed Gully for a well worked try. The full back also converted.


Time was running out and Swansea began to throw the kitchen sink at the Quins defence as they went in search for a losing bonus point. First replacement prop Alex Williams powered forward, and then Gallagher, who offloaded to replacement flanker Ross Barnes. However Quins full back Gwion Jones intercepted a pass on his twenty-two and raced clear to score under the posts. Marshall converted.


In the dying moments Price was yellow carded for an off the ball challenge, but it was the last play as Brace blew up for full time.


Next up for Carmarthen is a trip to Cardiff, while Swansea travel to Bedwas – both in the Principality Premiership.


Full-time:-   Carmarthen   33   Swansea   14


Carmarthen scorers:


Tries:-   Penalty try (16), Callum Price (37), Morgan Griffiths (40+4), Andrew Green (51), Gwion Jones (80+1)

Cons:-   Steffan Marshall (17, 38, 40+5, 80+2)


Yellow cards:-   Callum Price (80+2)


Swansea scorers:


Tries:-   Will Lewis (19), Ewan Gully (71)

Cons:-   Jac Wilson (20), Phil Jones (72)


Yellow cards:-   Rory Gallagher (16)


Match facts:


Venue:-   The Park, Carmarthen

Referee:-   Richard Brace

Weather:-   Clear, 10C

Man of the match:-   Andrew Green

Attendance:-   400


Carmarthen team:


15 Gwion Jones

14 Kieran Jones

13 Elliot Davies (rep: Craig Evans 53)

12 Callum Price

11 Morgan Griffiths (rep: Lee Williams 51)

10 Steffan Marshall

9 Ifan Thomas (rep: Aled James 32)

1 Steffan Phillips (rep: Connor Allen 69)

2 Rhodri Clancy

3 Javan Sebastian

4 Rhys Minchkin (rep: Ben Thompson 50)

5 Lee Taylor

6 Andrew Green (rep: Lewis Roberts 69)

7 Lewis Millin (rep: Charlie Randall 59)

8 Shaun Jones




16 Connor Allen

17 Lewis Roberts

18 Nathan Williams

19 Ben Thompson

20 Charlie Randall

21 Craig Evans

22 Lee Williams

23 Aled James


Swansea team:


15 Phil Jones

14 Jonathan Bayliss

13 Ewan Gully (rep: Lewis Humphries 72)

12 David Watts

11 Will Lewis

10 Jac Wilson (rep: Luc Caines 48)

9 Rhodri Wells (rep: Mike Jones 69)

1 Richard Murphy (rep: Ali Wade 46)

2 Alex Dunham (rep: George Jawad 53)

3 Mitchell Walsh (rep: Alex Williams 59)

4 Rhys Morgan (rep: Will Ponty 63)

5 Matthew Donohoe

6 Chris James (rep: Ross Barnes 69)

7 Rory Gallagher

8 Jon Fox ©




16 George Jawad

17 Ali Wade

18 Alex Williams

19 Will Ponty

20 Ross Barnes

21 Mike Jones

22 Lewis Humphries

23 Luc Caines


Attendance: 300

Official : Chris Oliver (Wales)

Quins Swansea